Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
- Head Editor
- Jun 10, 2023
- 2 min read
Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Kirby JJ
Facts: The case of Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 HCA involved a dispute over the ownership and copyright of a photograph taken during the Sydney Olympic Games in 2000. Roberta Fox, a professional photographer, captured an image of Cathy Freeman, an Australian sprinter, carrying both the Australian and Aboriginal flags after winning a gold medal. Fox later sought to enforce her copyright and claimed that her permission should be obtained before the photograph could be used.
The respondent in the case, Tony Percy, was the editor of The Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) newspaper. Percy reproduced the photograph without obtaining Fox's permission, arguing that the photograph was taken in a public place and, therefore, no permission was necessary. Fox disagreed and contended that her photograph should be considered an artistic work protected by copyright law.
Issue: The High Court of Australia considered two main issues in this case:
1. Whether the photograph could be considered an artistic work protected by copyright.
2. Whether the reproduction of the photograph constituted a fair dealing for the purpose of reporting the news.
Regarding the first issue, the High Court of Australia (HCA) held that the photograph taken by Fox was an artistic work protected by copyright. The Court recognized the skill and creativity involved in capturing the moment and deemed the photograph to possess the qualities of originality and expression required for copyright protection.
However, on the second issue, the Court found in favour of Percy. They concluded that the reproduction of the photograph by The Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) constituted a fair dealing for the purpose of reporting the news. The Court emphasized the importance of freedom of the press and held that the reproduction of the photograph was within the bounds of legitimate news reporting and public interest.
Conclusion: In summary, while Fox's photograph was deemed to be protected by copyright, its reproduction by The Sydney Morning Herald was considered a fair dealing for the purpose of reporting news, thus not infringing on Fox's copyright.
The website Heicx provides services for HEIC files, such as:
1.Heic to JPG
2.Heic to MP4
3.Heic to RAW
4.Heic Viewer
5.open heic file
6.Domain Availability Checker - Check domain availability across multiple top-level domains.
7.Domain Name Generator- Generate domain names of different styles for you.
8.Explore the world of Sprunki,a music creation game inspired by Incredibox. Download the game, meet characters, join the community, and create amazing music mixes. Discover fanart, lore, and more!
9.Audio Cutter: Trim and edit audio files easily with our intuitive online tool. Supports multiple formats and precise cutting. Get started now!
10.Key and BPM Finder
11.Audio Looper
12.Mp3 Joiner
13.Our AI Image Generator is a powerful tool that allows you to transform your ideas into stunning visuals with just a…
Fox v Percy highlights copyright protection for artistic works. It reminds me of navigating the digital landscape in games like Snow Rider , where ownership and usage rights are crucial. Even capturing a virtual moment requires respecting digital property. The court considered whether reproducing a photograph of Cathy Freeman was fair dealing for news reporting. Understanding these legal precedents is vital, just like mastering the slopes in Snow Rider while respecting boundaries.
While I understand the copyright argument, especially for artistic works, the photo's newsworthiness and public interest element seem substantial. The event was of national significance, and limiting its use could hinder historical record. Isn't there a balance to be struck between protecting an artist's rights and informing the public on key cultural moments? Perhaps overzealous enforcement stems from... Bad Parenting
O KMSPico Ativador é ideal para usuários domésticos e profissionais que precisam de uma solução rápida. Ele ativa Windows e Office sem complicações. Com o KMSPico Ativador, você elimina mensagens irritantes e ativa todos os recursos do sistema. Faça o download da versão mais atualizada do KMSPico Ativador aqui no site. Ativação simples, gratuita e definitiva — só com KMSPico Ativador.
bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; bengbengtoto bengbengtoto; situs online terpercaya